OXO Brew 8-Cup vs OXO Brew 9-Cup: the timer is the whole decision
Updated by Isadora Venn. Links to Amazon earn us a commission (how that works).
These two OXO machines share a brand, a temperature claim and a thermal carafe. The OXO Brew 8-Cup vs OXO Brew 9-Cup question comes down to whether you'll set a timer, and whether the SCA's certification matters to you.
Short answer
OXO Brew 8-Cup or OXO Brew 9-Cup? Get the 9-Cup if you want coffee ready when you wake up. Get the 8-Cup for SCA certification and a single-serve basket.
Both quote water at 194 to 205°F. Both use vacuum-insulated carafes, which means the coffee you pour at ten in the morning comes out of the same kind of insulated pot whichever machine you pick, and tastes much closer to the first cup than anything kept warm on a hot plate. They usually sell within a few dollars of each other, so price rarely settles it.
Side by side
| Spec | OXO Brew 8-Cup | OXO Brew 9-Cup |
|---|---|---|
| Type | Drip Amazon listing | Drip Amazon listing |
| Capacity | 8 cups Amazon listing | 9 cups Amazon listing |
| SCA certified | Certified 2025 SCA certified list | Not on the current list SCA certified list |
| Carafe | Double-wall vacuum thermal Amazon listing | Double-wall vacuum thermal Amazon listing |
| Grinder | None Amazon listing | None Amazon listing |
| Water path (maker) | White plastic brew basket Amazon listing | Not listed Amazon listing |
| Height | 13.5 in (10.5 x 7 in footprint) Amazon listing | Not listed Amazon listing |
| Warranty | 2 years Amazon listing | Not listed Amazon listing |
| Full pot time | Not listed Amazon listing | Not listed Amazon listing |
| Water temp | 194 to 205°F Amazon listing | 194 to 205°F Amazon listing |
| Single cup | Yes, with the single-serve basket Amazon listing | Two-cup batches (BetterBrew) Amazon listing |
| Buy | See OXO Brew 8-Cup on Amazon | See OXO Brew 9-Cup on Amazon |
The 9-Cup's listing leaves out height and warranty. The 8-Cup's listing gives both: 13.5 in tall and two years.
Which one
Choose the 8-Cup if
- You want the SCA mark on the box.
- You often brew just one mug.
- Your cabinets are low and you need a confirmed height.
Choose the 9-Cup if
- You'll program it every night.
- You like a single dial for everything.
- A freshness timer on the pot appeals to you.
Where they differ
Programming. The 9-Cup has a clock and a wake-up timer, set from one dial. The 8-Cup has neither. You press brew, and that's the end of the interface, which some people find restful and others find limiting the first morning they oversleep.
Certification. The SCA lists the OXO Brew 8-Cup (2025 entry) and an OXO 12-Cup from 2023. The 9-Cup wasn't on the list when we checked on Oct. 27, 2026. Both machines claim the same temperature range, so this may be about licensing rather than performance.
Single serving. The 8-Cup ships a single-serve basket that brews directly into a mug. The 9-Cup's BetterBrew system adjusts for small batches of about two cups, which isn't quite the same thing.
Evidence. The Coffee Locator named the 9-Cup its best value drip maker in April 2026. America's Test Kitchen and Tom's Guide both point to the 8-Cup. Different reviewers tested different OXO models, which is why roundups seem to disagree.
Size. One cup apart on paper. In mugs, that's a rounding error, so don't let the names steer you toward the 9-Cup if a timer isn't something you'd use at least most nights of the week.
Worries both answer
Can it make just one cup?
The 8-Cup does this better with its dedicated single-serve basket.
OXO 8-Cup: single-serve brew basket included (Amazon listing). OXO 9-Cup: BetterBrew small-batch cycles (Amazon listing).
FAQ
OXO Brew 8-Cup vs OXO Brew 9-Cup: which should I buy?
The 9-Cup if you'll use a timer; the 8-Cup otherwise.
OXO Brew 9-Cup vs OXO Brew 8-Cup: is one hotter?
Both listings quote 194 to 205°F at the grounds. Only the 8-Cup is on the SCA's current certified list.
Do both OXO machines have thermal carafes?
Yes, both thermal versions use double-wall vacuum-insulated carafes. OXO also sells an 8-Cup with a glass carafe.
Which OXO is better for a small kitchen?
The 8-Cup, because its listing confirms 13.5 in tall and 7 in wide.